Well water vs city water: which is right for your home?
Neither one is better in general. Well water vs city water turns on where the property sits and who takes care of the system. On city water, a public water system tests the water and sends you a bill. On a private well, the system is yours: you pay for its upkeep and answer for the water quality.
For many rural homes, there is no choice to make. Where no water system reaches the parcel, the well is the water. About 15 percent of the U.S. population, over 43 million people, rely on private wells, per the EPA.
Big River Drilling drills new and replacement water wells across Fresno, Kings and Tulare counties. The same company sets the pump and the pressure tank and runs the lines to the house.
What are the pros and cons of well water and city water?
City water, also called municipal water, hands most of the work to the water system. A well hands the work and the decisions to you.
| What to compare | City water | Private well |
|---|---|---|
| Who answers for water quality | The water system | You, the well owner |
| Testing and reports | A yearly water quality report, sent by July 1 | No report; the EPA advises a lab test every year |
| What you pay and when | A water bill all year, plus hookup costs for a new connection | The well, pump and tank up front, then power and repairs |
| Pressure | Set by the water system | Set by your pressure switch and pressure tank |
| Power outages | A power cut at your house does not stop the city’s pumps | The pump stops; only the water in the pressure tank is left |
| Drought and supply | The water system manages its supply | Your water depends on the groundwater under your parcel |
| Upkeep | The water system keeps up its pipes and pumps | You keep up the pump, the tank, the switch and the lines |
Neither column wins on every line. The right fit depends on your parcel, the water under it and how much upkeep you want to take on.
Who is responsible for the water quality?
On city water, the water system is. The EPA requires a community water system to send its customers a yearly water quality report, the Consumer Confidence Report. It goes out each year by July 1.
Dinuba shows how that works in the valley. Its city system pumps groundwater and runs each active well through a chlorination point. One city well was taken out of service in 2009 for high nitrate.
On a private well, the job is yours. The EPA says private well owners are responsible for the safety of their own drinking water. Private wells are not regulated under the federal Safe Drinking Water Act. The State of California does not regulate their water quality either.
Fresno County says private wells are not required to meet any water quality standards. The county takes a free sample from a new domestic well after its final inspection.
The EPA advises testing a private well every year for total coliform bacteria, nitrates, total dissolved solids and pH. In Tulare County, nitrates are the most common contaminant, per the county’s environmental health division. For new or deepened wells, the county encourages tests for bacteria and nitrates, and for DBCP in the valley.
DBCP, a farm chemical once used against nematodes, was banned in 1977 but still persists in the environment. The county lists the drinking water limit for nitrates at 45 parts per million. A state-certified lab runs these tests, and we can point you to one.
What does each one cost, and when do you pay?
On cost, city water vs well water is a choice between a steady bill and costs that come in lumps. The EPA says the average family spends more than $1,000 a year on water costs.
Joining a city system costs money too. A home-repair cost guide puts hooking up to city water at $1,000 to $6,000 or more. Where the city charges for the meter on its own, the guide lists $300 to $800 for it. Connection fees can add more, and the distance from the house to the main line drives much of the cost.
A well has no water bill. You pay for the well itself up front. After that, the costs are the power for the pump and the parts that wear out. Our guide to what a new well costs in the Central Valley covers the up-front side.
When the pump wears out, what a well pump replacement costs lays out the market ranges. The tank wears out too, and well pressure tank replacement is part of owning a well. A sudden jump in your power bill can mean the pump is running longer than usual. The dollar figures here are market numbers, not our price list.
How does a well handle pressure and power outages?
On city water, the pressure comes from the water system. On a well, it comes from the pump, a pressure switch and a pressure tank. The switch turns the pump on when the pressure drops and off when it builds back up.
Many well systems run at 40 psi on and 60 psi off, per a water well trade journal. The tank holds the water you use between pump starts. Low pressure, air in the lines or a pump that will not shut off is a well pump repair call.
A well pump runs on electricity. When the power goes out, the pump stops, and the house has only the water left in the pressure tank. Once that is used up, the taps stay dry until the power returns, unless the well has backup power.
If the water stops while the power is on, start with what to check when the water stops. It walks through the breaker, the pressure gauge and the switch.
What happens to a well in a drought?
A well depends on the groundwater under your parcel. When the water level drops below the pump, the well can go dry. California’s Department of Water Resources has logged 6,222 household water shortage reports statewide.
Fresno, Kings and Tulare counties carry a big share. Tulare County has 1,874 reports, Fresno County 821 and Kings County 164. That is 2,859 in the three counties, about 46 percent of the state’s total.
SGMA, the state’s groundwater law, puts local agencies in charge of managing groundwater. The Kings Subbasin, for one, has seven groundwater sustainability agencies. Its annual report says water levels generally fall in normal to dry years and rise in wet years.
On city water, the supply is the water system’s job. On a well, a dry year shows up at your own tap.
What if there is no city water at your parcel?
Then the well is your water system. That is the case for many rural homes, ranchettes and farmhouses across the valley. If a city line runs past your parcel, ask the city whether you can connect and what its fees are.
Buying a home on a well? Ask the seller for the well’s records, recent lab results and the age of the pump and the tank. A pump or tank near the end of its life is a cost to plan for.
Building on bare land? Plan the well along with the house. The well, the pump, the tank and the lines all come before water runs at the tap.
How do you get started on a new or replacement well?
Big River Drilling is a licensed C-57 well drilling contractor based in Riverdale. We drill new and replacement water wells by mud rotary. Then we set the pump and the pressure tank and run the lines, so water runs at the house.
A free on-site estimate starts from the well records nearby. It spells out the depth range, the casing, the seal, the pump and the tank for your property. We take well and pump calls 24 hours a day, seven days a week. To get your estimate, call or text (559) 867-3806.